WEAVE
WEAVE-Apertif survey

Weave logo

Survey Strategy

Observing modes   —  Observational requirements   —   Main sample selection   —  Bad-Weather program

 

1. Observing modes

We will conduct the WEAVE-Apertif survey in two observing modes:
 
  • Tier-1 (LR sample), performed with the LR mode (R~2500) of the LIFU, will draw WEAVE targets from the parent sample of galaxies with resolved HI distributions classified as described below based on data from the Apertif shallow wide-area survey and medium-deep surveys. These observations will cover the spectral range between 3660 -- 9840Å. They will be focussed on the evolutionary state of galaxies revealed by HI, including members of the blue cloud and the red sequence, and provide a representative sample of 400 objects over a broad range of HI content and morphology in different environments.
  • Tier-2 (HR sample) will follow up a subset of 100 galaxies from Tier-1 with the HR mode (R~10000) of the LIFU. We will take advantage of the dual-arm capabilities of WEAVE to observe simultaneously between 4730-5450Å and 5950-6950Å. Typical exposure times will suffice to match the depth of the LR data.

The combination of the LR and HR datasets will allow us to explore the goals highlighted here from different perspectives.

2. Observational requirements

Reaching our scientific goals requires of a minimum set of observational constraints for the LIFU observations. We decided on the following conditions based on extensive tests with the Exposure Time Calculator (ETC) developed by Scott Trager for the WEAVE consortium:

  • Seeing: below 2.0’’ (seeing above 2’’ is considered ’bad-weather’)
  • Airmass: maximum of 1.5 (i.e., 42deg elevation)
  • Sky brightness:
    • Dark ( V=21.5 mag arcsec2) for the HR sample
    • Gray ( V=20.5 mag arcsec2) for LR and bad weather samples.
  • Exposure times: 1 hr per galaxy in LR mode and 3 hr per galaxy in HR mode

3. Main sample selection

 
3.1 HI classification
The study of the origin and nature of the apparent bimodality in the global properties of galaxies requires an extensive multivariate analysis of their spatially resolved physical properties, such as morphology, stellar and dynamical mass distribution, star formation rate, recent star formation history and physical state of the ISM. For this purpose, a large number of galaxies detected in HI across all cosmic environments should be observed with WEAVE’s LIFU.

An absolutely essential study would investigate galaxy properties as a function of HI morphology, stellar mass, specific star formation rate (sSFR), and local environment. We split the sample in:
 
  • 3 HI morphological bins (i.e. regular / lopsided / disturbed)
  • 2 sSFR bins (i.e. on/off the main star-forming sequence)
  • 4 bins in stellar mass, and 2 bins for local environment (i.e. low density [isolated/field] versus high density [groups/clusters]).
  • We expect to also probe the HI mass content over a large dynamical range
With the target number of 400 galaxies, this implies having at least 9 galaxies in each bin, which is sufficient to identify global trends. We define the HI morphological bins as: (1) Regular, symmetric HI discs (including symmetric warps), (2) Asymmetric/lopsided HI discs (including both morphological and kinematic lopsidedness, but the disc must be clearly recognisable) and (3) Unsettled HI distributions (an HI disc might be present but most of the HI must be heavily disturbed/unsettled). The three groups should give us systems covering a range in strength of (and/or elapsed time since) the latest major evolutionary event. Groups 2 and 3 will also cover a variety of physical processes affecting galaxy evolution, including tidal and hydro-dynamical interactions.
 
The primary parent sample for our secular-evolution studies will be the HR sample, where the Apertif beam size is appropriate for the physical scales of interest (~1 kpc). Galaxies in this sample will not be part of the disturbed HI morphological bin and will belong to the regular and lopsided categories, still covering all the other selection parameters as described above. That way we ensure there will be at least 2 to 3 galaxies in each bin.
 
3.2 Optical constraints
WEAVE-Apertif will deliver a representative sample of HI-selected galaxies. Since WEAVE will deliver LIFU optical observations, it is of paramount importance to establish a minimum set of criteria to obtain a useful LIFU dataset. In order to maximise the quality of the optical data, and to minimize the exposure times required for our LIFU observations, we remove galaxies with apparent magnitude mg≤16 mag and redshift≤0.042.
 
In addition we applied the following restrictions to ensure we can fulfill the scientific cases outlined above:
 
  • Target SNR 40 per Å. Since we aim to derive robust stellar kinematics and stellar population parameters, we set the minimum SNR target on the continuum to 40 per Å per spatial bin (see, e.g., Falcón-Barroso et al., 2006; Peletier et al., 2007).
  • g = 24 mag/arcsec2 within the LIFU FoV. Typical breaks in surface brightness profiles of disk galaxies occur about 0.5 mag before this limit. The study of radial migration in galaxies requires probing past this point.
  • Inclination ≤70deg. We impose this limit for galaxies in our main sample to optimize the use of the LIFU FoV.
  • Minimum number of Voronoi bins for target SNR. In order to maximize the number of objects for the main sample, and still reach the target SNR, we decided to impose radial binning (e.g. doing azimuthal averaging) for the LR sample. For the HR sample we decided to do Voronoi binning, so that we can respect the 2D distribution of the relevant physical parameters on similar scales (or better) to that provided by the HI data. We set the minimum number of bins in each case to 6 and 20 respectively.

4. Bad-Weather program

Our Bad-Weather(BW) plan is meant to use the worse observing conditions at the observatory to provide the scheduler with targets that are not part of our main WA survey (and thus will not address our main science goals), but can be useful for other purposes. The plan proposed here is complementary to our survey and will allow addressing some of the areas not covered by the main WA sample. We will achieve this by relaxing some of the most stringent constraints imposed on the main sample.

The main restriction we will impose on the BW sample is that it must contain galaxies that can be observed with a single 1 h OB in gray sky conditions with seeing above 2.0’’. This is important to make sure only bright, and mostly large galaxies, make it to the BW sample. We will also allow observations up to 1.7 in airmass (i.e. 33deg elevation) to give the maximum flexibility to the scheduler. In addition, we will also remove or soften the following conditions:

  • No restriction to stay within the Apertif footprint. By removing this condition we will allow for a much more flexible scheduling, since galaxies with declinations below +27 (i.e. the Apertif limit) could be observed. That will allow us to venture into the ALFALFA (Giovanelli, 2007) survey to obtain upper limit HI mass estimates.
  • No inclination restriction. This will allow edge-on systems to be observed. Many of them will not be completely spatially resolved with the LIFU in the direction perpendicular to the disk plane, and thus will make it difficult for thick disk studies. Nevertheless, they may contain off-plane ionised gas features that are relevant to investigate environmental process in action, specially if connected with the HI distribution.
  • No surface brightness restriction within FoV. This will allow bigger galaxies to be observed. We will carefully inspect all the candidates to make sure they are still small or flattened enough not to cause problems with sky subtraction (i.e. avoiding sky fibres in the LIFU being contaminated by stellar light from the galaxy).
  • Allow for small (<0.2’), high surface brightness galaxies. Our main WA sample has a typical size (i.e. semi-major axis length of the 24 mag arcsec2 isophote) of 0.4’, with a minimum of 0.2’. This is due to the restrictions in the level of binning we are imposing. We will relief that limit somewhat to allow for small but high surface brightness galaxies, e.g. Markarian galaxies, that usually display peculiar HI properties.

All these conditions will give the observatory the maximum scheduling flexibility, while providing galaxies with properties rather different from those in the main WA sample.